More Thoughts on Stephenie Meyer

I am enjoying the second installment of Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight series.  I wish Bella had a bit more self-esteem, but I can certainly relate to her.  She is like a lot of teenage girls, which is why I think she’s so popular.  It occurred to me as I was reading today that my own daughter’s writing style is somewhat similar to Meyer’s.  I am sure she would consider that a compliment, but I’m not sure it was conscious on her part.  The piece I am thinking of Sarah wrote a year ago or more, and I’m not sure she was into Twilight yet at that point.

That said, while I think she is the “next big thing” in the way that J.K. Rowling was the “big thing” in children’s/YA lit., I’m not sure that her stories are as grand in scale.  Harry Potter is an epic of the sort that I believe Joseph Campbell would have enjoyed in the same way he enjoyed Star Wars.  I don’t see the heroic journey as the dramatic underpinning of Twilight.  There is the sense of the bildündsroman about it, but that could be said of many works of YA lit, I think.  However, in a certain remarkable respect, Meyer does remind me of Rowling: reluctant readers are picking up her books in the same way they did Rowling’s books.  For example, I had a student last semester who was a self-professed non-reader.  I told her I thought she would like these books.  I think because I made personal recommendation, she felt obligated to try the first one.  She loved it and read the following books in rapid succession and even convinced another English teacher on our faculty to try them (and she loved them, too).  Her mother nearly broke down in tears of gratitude during a conference.  All I did was suggest.  That gratitude really belongs to Stephenie Meyer.

Stephenie Meyer Redux

I am once again reading Stephenie Meyer.  I have been meaning to get to New Moon and Eclipse for some time, but I just hadn’t for various reasons.  Meyer has a real gift for action and moving a story along.  If I have a criticism, I have to say I find Bella’s self-deprecation and idol-worship of Edward annoying sometimes, but I know I’m in for another good read.  The book starts with something of a bang, and I was really excited to learn my birthday is only four days after Bella’s.

I wonder if Barnes and Noble will do a midnight event for the release of Breaking Dawn.  I have speculated before that Meyer just might be the next J.K. Rowling, and I know that at least in my area, her books are popular enough to warrant a midnight release party.

Incidentally, if you want to keep up with what I’m reading, check the sidebar.  I always update when I finish a book and start a new one.

The Commoner

John Burnham Schwartz acknowledges in an author’s note at the beginning of his novel The Commoner that it is inspired by people and incidents connected to the Japanese Imperial family.  Empress Michiko is the first commoner to marry into the Imperial family in its 1000-year history.  As crown princess, she and her husband, the then Crown Prince Akihito also broke tradition by deciding to raise their own children rather than send them away.

The story is told from the viewpoint of its protagonist, Haruko, the only daughter of a wealthy sake brewing company owner, who meets the crown prince of the Imperial family on the tennis court.  A somewhat awkward courtship followed, and Haruko became the crown princess.  The empress, her new mother-in-law, made it clear that she disapproved of her son’s wife and made her feel like an unwelcome outsider — even to the point of appointing ladies in waiting who spied on the princess and delivered the princess her mother-in-law’s decrees regarding Haruko’s behavior and the empress’ expectations for improvement.  When Haruko tries to assert herself upon giving birth to her son, Yasu, the empress effectively breaks Haruko’s spirit.  Years later, Haruko must make a difficult decision when she sees the weight of being a part of the Imperial family crushing her own daughter-in-law.

Truthfully, though Schwartz insists this book is a work of fiction, the story differs from that of its inspiration principally in the ending alone.  Many of the events Haruko, Schwartz’s Michiko, describes really happened to the Empress as well.  In addition, Crown Princess Masako has also suffered problems similar to those of Schwartz’s Keiko.

While the novel concerns the Japanese court, it is really the story of women.  Throughout history, women of all backgrounds have been subjugated in the way Haruko and her daughter-in-law were.  Oppressed by tradition, duty, and even, as in the case of Haruko, other women, these women were silenced.  It did not matter that they were as intelligent and capable (and often more so) as the men in their lives.  Their places in society were fixed.  I was actually reminded of Princess Diana as I read.  I think it must be difficult for women who enter into marriages with men who are part of establishments like monarchies — always saying or doing the wrong thing, never able to make their in-laws happy, all their efforts focused on giving birth to a male heir.

The novel is a love letter to those women who have been unable to tell their own stories.  I really enjoyed it.  Schwartz’s symbolism is careful and appropriate.  I liked his writing style — I felt it evoked the setting well.  I do not know much about Japan.  I did read an Amazon review that picked at some inaccuracies in the novel.  If you are quite familiar with Japan, perhaps these issues will bother you, too; however, I have to say that the majority of the reviewers agree with my own assessment that the novel is moving and beautifully written.  I might not have read the book if not for listening to this radio program about it, which says more than I can in a simple review:

Download link

You can learn more about the Emperor and Empress of Japan and their son, Crown Prince Naruhito and his wife the Crown Princess Masako.

Book Clubs

I have never truly been in a book club. Not because I don’t want to, but because the opportunity simply hasn’t presented itself. And I really want to be in a book club! I teach literature, and I love it, but sometimes I want to discuss books with grown ups. I love blogging about reading and books here, but the immediate interaction of a discussion is missing. I also enjoyed discussing professional development reading on a forum, but the conversation was sometimes stilted due to the course requirements. I would love to talk about books with a group of people who chose a book to read for pleasure instead of a course requirement.

Any suggestions on getting started?

The World is Flat

The World is FlatI found Thomas Friedman’s The World is Flat to be an intriguing book. Friedman’s thesis is that a series of “flatteners,” or world-changing events, converged at just the right time to make the world’s playing field level and allow countries such as India and China opportunities to compete with America and Europe. Largely, I saw very little in Friedman’s book to disagree with. He acknowledges that the same tools we use for good in this new and increasingly global economy can be used for evil. He references terrorists and has interesting insights into their motivation for destruction and the reasons for their hate. I do think Friedman’s view of what will happen as the world becomes increasingly flat, to use his term, is optimistic, but frankly, I think a lot of it would be good for us. I think Friedman somewhat dismisses the plight of American workers who lose their jobs to outsourcing, but he has a good solution — we need to learn to adapt and to make ourselves special so we are more attractive job candidates. I think that solution is more realistic than the one that seems to be favored by many others — punish companies who outsource and try to force companies into doing business the way they did in the past. Life goes on, and things change. We have to change with them, or we will be left behind.

I think one of the biggest favors we can do ourselves is invest in green technology. We are way too dependent on foreign oil. Oil is a stick that countries we otherwise would have hardly any trade relations with use against us. Their economies are dependent on oil, and when it runs out, they’re going to be in serious trouble.

I am really excited about the potential for collaboration that exists. I love it that we can work together across miles. Through this blog I have made friends from all over America and a few in other countries. We’d never have “met” if not for flat world technologies like blogs. I have learned so much from technology and have developed so much passion for Web 2.0 ideas — which are nothing more than flattening agents online — that I am pursuing my masters degree — online — in Instructional Technology beginning this fall.

I also like the idea that businesses have to be transparent. Your reputation is important, and you can no longer manage it completely. If someone isn’t happy with your goods or services, they can complain in a blog or forum, and you might lose customers. I recently complained about the spurious business practices of Urban Posters, and I had lots of feedback from other customers who were treated the same way, in addition to a hollow apology that blamed the credit card processing company from an Urban Posters representative. People were angry about their money being taken, and they said so in a public forum. Now when someone searches for information about this company, this negative feedback will perhaps prevent someone else from being taken in. I think that’s a fantastic thing to come out of the flat world.

This book is an investment. It’s long, and I think it requires a lot of reflection and thinking on the part of the reader. If you are interested in a beach book or a quick read, this book is not what you’re looking for; however, if you are interested in the times in which we live and emerging ideas and technology, this book will fascinate you.

Another Independent Bookseller Closes Up Shop

Coffee Buy the Book, an independent bookseller right down the road from my house, is closing. As I drove by the shop this evening, I noticed a large banner covering the store’s sign: “Going out of Business — Everything Must Go.”

I have only been in the store twice, and it was empty both times. Coffee Buy the Book has a warm, inviting atmosphere with places to sit, coffee (of course), and a good selection of books. It’s a nice little shop, and it is a shame to see it go. However, given that I never saw many customers, I suppose it was a matter of time before it closed.

I would like to see independent booksellers be successful, but to be honest, I do very little to support them. I order books from Amazon or purchase them at Borders or Barnes and Noble, even though Coffee Buy the Book is just down the road and is open reasonable hours. One of those things I always meant to do was become a customer at the store. I never did, and now it will be too late.

The first time I went to Coffee Buy the Book, I met a fellow Bookcrosser (I no longer participate in Bookcrossing) to chat. We sat for a long time talking and no one ever bothered us. The second time, I popped in after a meeting at Maggie’s school to see if they had any Ramona Quimby books. I found Ramona the Pest for Maggie, got a great deal on it, and left.

It’s funny. Even though I wondered how this little shop stayed in business and I liked the idea of it, I never did my part to keep it in business, and now, well, I am sad it’s closing. I suppose the least I can do is stop by before they close and see if I can help them dispose of their stock.

Neil Gaiman on Free Books

Neil Gaiman fielded a question from an independent bookseller who was surprised by some of Gaiman’s recent comments regarding free books.  The bookseller wondered if offering books for free wouldn’t be preventing readers from buying the books from booksellers.  In honor of his blog’s seventh anniversary, Gaiman allowed readers to vote for which book in his catalog they’d like to see available online for a month, and readers selected American Gods.

Gaiman’s original words really spoke to me as an English teacher: “The problem isn’t that books are given away or that people read books they haven’t paid for. The problem is that the majority of people don’t read for pleasure.”

Gaiman’s well-reasoned response to the bookseller is worth a read.  As Gaiman astutely noted in another post, “Word of mouth is still the best tool for selling books.”  I can’t remember how many times good reviews on Amazon or from a friend or colleague or even a TV or radio program have made me buy a book I might not have purchased otherwise.

A few times I have lent books to students only to never have them returned.  While I miss my books, in a way, it’s almost better if they aren’t returned.  It means they were really enjoyed, and I would rather put that in my students’ hands than have my book.  It looks like Neil Gaiman feels the same way.

Adding to the List

I have some books to add to my to-read list.

Thank goodness I have finished Classroom Instruction That Works.  Maybe I can focus a bit on some pleasure reading.

Round-up

Sylvia has a very interesting post about book clubs for homeless citizens.  I sent an e-mail to my students in National Honor Society (I am the sponsor for my school’s chapter) asking if they might be interested in doing something similar or at least holding a book drive for a shelter.  Thanks for sharing it, Sylvia.

I purchased The Commoner by John Burnham Schwartz.  I need to finish my professional development books before I can start it.  I’m not one of those people that can have a whole stack of books going at once.  Two really seems to be my limit.  But after I finish, you can look for my thoughts on Schwartz’s novel here.  One of the most frustrating things about having to take these two courses is that it has really cut into my ability to read for pleasure.  Soon, this too, shall pass.  I could actually knock out one of the courses this weekend if I focus.

In completely non-related news, I have a mild concussion.  I am all right.  What happened was a glass full of pens and spare change decided to jump off my bookshelf and attack me.  I didn’t feel myself on Friday — sort of mildly queasy and dizzy.  But worse than that, I felt a bit disoriented.  I had trouble when I was talking with students remembering a colleague’s name.  I finally decided I had better go home.  I went to the doctor, and x-rays showed no fractures.  I have a fairly painful spot on my noggin and have been trying to rest.  I’m glad it wasn’t worse.